A Good Week For Books
Aug. 4th, 2005 06:00 amThis is turning out to be an unusually good week for books. First there was The Tiger in the Well, which had me sitting in my parked car for more than 90 minutes. Tuesday night it was HPB keeping both the child and I up until midnight because we Had To Know How It Turned Out. Yesterday, Jacqueline Carey's new book, Godslayer arrived, and I'm already deeply drawn back into those characters.
Many months ago, I posted that her first book of this series, Banewreaker, was a strangely compelling blending of The Lord of the Rings and Paradise Lost. The LOTR aspects are so blatant the book shouldn't work at all. This volume even has on its cover an image of a "white wizard" riding bareback on a white horse -- someone who had apparently died in an underground battle trying to protect his "company" who had gathered to protect the small person carrying the only thing that can destroy the enemy. Can't get much more blatant than that. Unless you count Aracus Altorus, the Ranger-like King of the West, who was about to marry an Elven -- excuse me: Ellyon -- princess.
What makes the difference is the Opposition. Carey doesn't present a simple Good vs. Evil universe. The "bad guys" have their own story, their own honor, their own grievances -- and are unique, sympathetic, and intriguing characters in their own right. Instead of orcs as shock troops: stupid, brutal cannon-fodder, you have the Fjel, who are a race with their own strengths and weaknesses -- and, again, are allowed to have honor, friendship, loyalty, and grief. They are a race who can build and nurture as well as destroy.
Cerelinde, the Ellyon princess, is far more interesting than Arwen and has a better storyline. She is kidnapped on her wedding day in order to prevent the fulfillment of a prophecy, and she now has an unsettling close-up view of those she was raised to hate. And then there is Lilia, a mortal woman turned sorceress who was the custodian of a magic stone for centuries, and a friend of a dragon -- both now lost thanks to Aracus's efforts to rescue Cerelinde.
It shouldn't work. But it does.
Many months ago, I posted that her first book of this series, Banewreaker, was a strangely compelling blending of The Lord of the Rings and Paradise Lost. The LOTR aspects are so blatant the book shouldn't work at all. This volume even has on its cover an image of a "white wizard" riding bareback on a white horse -- someone who had apparently died in an underground battle trying to protect his "company" who had gathered to protect the small person carrying the only thing that can destroy the enemy. Can't get much more blatant than that. Unless you count Aracus Altorus, the Ranger-like King of the West, who was about to marry an Elven -- excuse me: Ellyon -- princess.
What makes the difference is the Opposition. Carey doesn't present a simple Good vs. Evil universe. The "bad guys" have their own story, their own honor, their own grievances -- and are unique, sympathetic, and intriguing characters in their own right. Instead of orcs as shock troops: stupid, brutal cannon-fodder, you have the Fjel, who are a race with their own strengths and weaknesses -- and, again, are allowed to have honor, friendship, loyalty, and grief. They are a race who can build and nurture as well as destroy.
Cerelinde, the Ellyon princess, is far more interesting than Arwen and has a better storyline. She is kidnapped on her wedding day in order to prevent the fulfillment of a prophecy, and she now has an unsettling close-up view of those she was raised to hate. And then there is Lilia, a mortal woman turned sorceress who was the custodian of a magic stone for centuries, and a friend of a dragon -- both now lost thanks to Aracus's efforts to rescue Cerelinde.
It shouldn't work. But it does.